Advice on which MA to choose - UAL vs Edinburgh Napier (1 Viewer)

alxschot

New Member
To preface I know I'm in the UK so I'm not looking for advice about what each specific course is like more just general advice on if my thought process on this is completely of base.

So I've received two offers for MA screenwriting courses, one at the University of the Arts London (UAL) and one at Edinburgh Napier/Screen Academy Scotland. I'll also say I'm genuinely surprised it's been this hard a choice Before my interviews UAL was basically my top choice (would've loved Goldsmiths but they rejected me and even if I had got in I couldn't afford to go)

In terms of cost they're pretty evenly matched - UAL is technically the most expensive but I'm eligible for a £5,000 fee reduction - and Edinburgh is barely any less expensive to live in than London. The problem is that one, I do prefer the course at Napier just slightly as there's a little bit more variety, Plus the overall structure seems more familiar to me as someone coming straight from a traditional undergraduate degree. The other more personal benefit Napier has is that I did my undergraduate at Glasgow so pretty much my entire social circle would be a 1 hour train ride away.

Honestly though any other year I'd say screw it and go to UAL anyway, the course is still great, it's in London which is a big location +, it's really well recognised in the industry and you get the opportunity to pitch to producers at the end of the course which just seems like an absolutely insane opportunity to pass up. Unfortunately COVID is bearing its ugly head, Napier is currently planning for complete in-person learning whereas UAL is planning for blended learning where one day a week is on zoom and the other is in person and I'm just not sure I can do it. I've spent a year staring at zoom squares and I'm just completely burned out, I hated it, I crawled over the finish line with my undergrad. Seriously, my last semester I went from getting solid Bs with a few As to not getting a final grade higher than a C. I struggled doing 2 hour classes on zoom, and at UAL it would be a 10-5 day online. But then who the hell knows what either city/country will look like in a month or two, Scotland is plague central right now (cases have started going back down though). On the other hand given England is throwing complete caution to the wind despite a rising case number I wouldn't be surprised if everything had to close again anyway. And having lived in Scotland for most of the pandemic I definitely have more long term faith that it'll get better rather than worse there.

Its also not like Napier has zero cool perks either, they've had some really cool guests, you get heavily discounted industry passes to Edinburgh film festival and both courses have opportunities to collaborate with MA film students to actually have something produced. And both courses are equally well accredited on paper.

And on a 100% subjective level I got much better vibes from the course leader at Napier than I did UAL during the interviews. The Napier guy just gave off a much more encouraging feeling and ended the interview by talking about how he genuinely enjoyed my sample pointing out specific things that he liked, whereas the UAL interviewer almost made it feel like I should be grateful they were even offering me a place if that makes sense? I know that sounds petty because I should be grateful but I struggle with imposter syndrome/anxiety at the best of times the last thing I want is to spend a year second guessing if I even deserve to be there. Obviously I can handle constructive criticism but I'm just worried if I go I'm gonna have this irrational voice in the back of my head the entire time.

Every time I go through it all It just feels like for every pro each one has they have an equal number of cons. It just keeps coming back to that end of year pitch at UAL though, like would I be an absolute lunatic to turn down that? Because it feels like it should be a no-brainer. On the other hand having the chance to pitch means nothing if I get there and do terribly.
 

Chris W

Willem was robbed
Staff member
I'm not sure if those programs are in our film school database yet if you want to add them:


I can probably add them later this weekend though if you are unable to.

Re your decision though.... Hmmm it's tough. One benefit of London would be that it would be a location change and that's sometimes very good for new experiences and getting the creative juices flowing. Stepping out of your comfort zone so to speak. (Unless you are very familiar with London)

And yes I am afraid that a lot is going to be locked down again if the idiots don't get vaccinated. I worry about that alot in the US... But really can't worry about that too much as it's really out of our control. So I'm not sure I'd base your selection on that.
 

Chris W

Willem was robbed
Staff member
Both of these programs have been added to our Application Tracker and the Film School Database. :)

University of the Arts London (UAL) - MA Screenwriting

University of the Arts London (UAL) - MA Screenwriting

MA Screenwriting is an industry-focused screenwriting course that develops writers and script editors for the film, television and radio industries.

Edinburgh Napier University - MA Screenwriting

Edinburgh Napier University - MA Screenwriting

The MA Screenwriting at Edinburgh Napier University was launched in 2006 and has adapted and developed since then to a point where we feel confident that this is one of the strongest screenwriting Masters courses on offer in the UK. While the course is principally for aspiring screenwriters, it...

Please add your applications to the site when you can.
 
Add your film school application to our Application Database so that we can improve our admissions statistics.

Add Application…

Student Films Made at Film Programs

A248
Views
47
Reaction score
1
One man's mission to document and preserve the history and pop culture of the San Fernando Valley in Southern California. Tommy Gelinas was born and raised in the San Fernando Valley in Southern California. He grew up visiting restaurants, malls, and many other venues that slowly declined and...
Film Program
Loyola Marymount University
Course
PROD 600
Film Type
Assignment
Genre
Documentary
Duration/Running Time
13:52
Film Completion
Dec 1, 2020
A248
Views
57
Reaction score
1
In the midst of a global pandemic, a very paranoid vampire orders contactless food delivery.
Film Program
Loyola Marymount University
Course
PROD 685
Film Type
Assignment
Genre
Comedy
Duration/Running Time
1:24
Film Completion
Aug 1, 2020
Colella612
Updated
3.00 star(s) 1 ratings
Views
271
Reaction score
2
Reviews
1
Questions
2
After the light bulb on her film projector burns out, an elderly woman must confront a nightmarish world as well as the trauma of her past as she seeks to find a replacement before her memories are lost forever.
Film Program
Loyola Marymount University
Course
Directing Short Film II: Visual Story
Film Type
Assignment
Genre
Drama
Duration/Running Time
5:58
Film Completion
May 3, 2021

Users who are viewing this thread


Latest Accepted Applications


Acceptance Data
For up to date Film School Acceptance Rates, including Minimum GPAs, Minimum Test Scores, After Interview and Off-Waitlist Acceptance Rates, Film Experience and Undergraduate degrees of accepted applicants, Age data, and other acceptance statistics for your film program of choice simply navigate to the Acceptance Rates tab on each film school's page in our Film School Database.

For example:
Add your own Application to our application database to help improve the site's acceptance data.

Latest Applications

Latest reviews

Latest questions

Latest Articles

Latest Accepted Applications

Top