I've been trying to make sense of the emails that people have been receiving.
I think they make sense when considering the NYU process. There are several rounds to finally getting an interview.
1.After the deadline, they gather all of the applications and send them off to a committee that is not the faculty. I'm not sure who these people are. They make a first cut and whittle down the hundreds (if not thousands) to a few hundred.
2. This next few hundred is sent back to NYU where they are divided amongst the faculty. Each person chooses a few applicants from their pool that they would like to interview. So at the end of this stage, there are about 100 people.
3. They interview all 100 or so people.
4. After the interviews they select about 40 of them for the class, plus a waitlist. Some people don't accept the offer, and the space goes to a waitlist person. At the end of the day, i think they want a class in the mid 30's or so.
So my assumption, which could be entirely incorrect is that, those people that got interviews were the people that didn't make it past round 1.
The people that have not heard back yet are in round 2 now. Maybe will get an interview, maybe not. Either way, no news is good news at this point.
Like I said, I could be completely wrong, but I think that's what's going on.