Columbia MFA Prompt Structure Advice

NEED ADVICE

How much can you alter the film prompts for Columbia's MFA Screenwriting application? I am sticking to the main details (time, location, age, relationships) but I want to change a few small details for my individual story, is that ok???

Mainly does the 2nd individual in the story HAS to be human?

Columbia film prompts (2-3pgs):

EXT. AMUSEMENT PARK – NIGHT
Alone in the open cabin of a ferris wheel, the Young Woman is frightened to hear the entire ride screech, then slow to a complete stop. Voices from below shout assurances that the problem will be fixed in a few minutes...but things get even worse when she turns to see the person sitting in the cabin hanging opposite her own.

INT. DEPARTMENT STORE – DAY
As the Teenager scans the clothing racks for something to buy, he’s startled to see what looks like someone hastily stuffing merchandise into their backpack. He looks for a salesperson or a security guard - but just then, the person slips away. He follows.
 

NEED ADVICE

How much can you alter the film prompts for Columbia's MFA Screenwriting application? I am sticking to the main details (time, location, age, relationships) but I want to change a few small details for my individual story, is that ok???

Mainly does the 2nd individual in the story HAS to be human?

Columbia film prompts (2-3pgs):

EXT. AMUSEMENT PARK – NIGHT
Alone in the open cabin of a ferris wheel, the Young Woman is frightened to hear the entire ride screech, then slow to a complete stop. Voices from below shout assurances that the problem will be fixed in a few minutes...but things get even worse when she turns to see the person sitting in the cabin hanging opposite her own.

INT. DEPARTMENT STORE – DAY
As the Teenager scans the clothing racks for something to buy, he’s startled to see what looks like someone hastily stuffing merchandise into their backpack. He looks for a salesperson or a security guard - but just then, the person slips away. He follows.
🤷‍♂️ It's not following the prompt but pretty darn close if everything else is the same. I guess it all depends on how good it is?

You're taking a risk not following application directions. However that being said technically everything in an appliance is somewhat of a risk. Something to keep in mind. I can't really advise either way. The only way to know for sure if they'd immediately set it aside for not exactly following the prompt is to call and ask as every school is different.

If you do call please report what they say.
 
🤷‍♂️ It's not following the prompt but pretty darn close if everything else is the same. I guess it all depends on how good it is?

You're taking a risk not following application directions. However that being said technically everything in an appliance is somewhat of a risk. Something to keep in mind. I can't really advise either way. The only way to know for sure if they'd immediately set it aside for not exactly following the prompt is to call and ask as every school is different.

If you do call please report what they say.
Would you consider the presentation of IT (aka Pennywise the Clown) a person? He looks almost human most of the time and then he changes into something more terrifying. Also, in real life clowns are just humans in make-up... so could I use a something along the idea of a shape-shifter or semi-human?
 
Log your film school application with our Application Database so that we can improve our admissions statistics.



Users who are viewing this thread


Latest Accepted Applications

This Application in the Scattergram

Unlock Film School Admissions Insights

Stop guessing about your chances. See exactly where you stand with real data from 5,000+ applications by becoming a Supporting Member.

This Application in the Scattergram

  • See applications plotted by GPA + Film Experience
  • View real outcomes: Admitted, Waitlisted, Denied, Awaiting Results
  • Hover for full application details

+ 45 Exclusive Admissions Charts

Acceptance rates, reapplication success, interview impact, portfolio breakdowns, and more.

Instant access • Cancel anytime

Latest Film School Reviews

  • San Diego State University - School of Theatre, Television, and Film
    3.00 star(s)
    Nothing special
    You really kind of get what you pay for with this program. It might be one of the cheapest programs out there but it’s also one of the most...
    • Anonymous
  • USC School of Cinematic Arts
    5.00 star(s)
    USC is a Lighthouse
    The School of Cinematic Arts has essentially been created in the image of a corporate film studio. Artistically successful films you make at this...
    • Anonymous
  • Full Sail University
    4.00 star(s)
    Self Motivated? You'll Do Fine
    I did the 27 month, online, Digital Cinematography Bachelor’s degree at Full Sail. It is basically a film degree with the added focus of trying to...
    • Pryde Pierce
  • Antioch University - Low-residency MFA in Creative Writing
    5.00 star(s)
    Invaluable Excitement
    I came into the MFA program as a novelist, with a focus on Fiction. I took the screenwriting elective that first semester, and was immediately...
    • Caledfwlch
  • Stony Brook University (SUNY)
    5.00 star(s)
    Small Cohort, Big Impact: My Experience at Stony Brook’s TV Writing MFA
    Hello fellow TV Writing and Filmmaking Community, I’m here to give you my two cents on the TV Writing MFA at Stony Brook University. I’m a...
    • garciabcarol

Latest Applications

Latest questions

  • Columbia University's School of the Arts
    I am checking to see if others have received notification that Columbia’s deadline for their MFA film application has been extended until December...
    • zk-writer-01
  • Stockholm University of Arts
    Hello. I am seriously thinking about applying to SKH, but I have no idea how the application process happens. Does anyone here know that? Thanks...
    • IgorCL
  • Syracuse University
    How about now after a whole year? How are the connections plus the production side of the sets?
    • anynonmous78
  • California Institute of the Arts (CalArts)
    Does anyone know the acceptance rate for the MFA in PFV and/or the Film Directing programs? Im thinking of applying for 2026
    • reproducibility_
  • NYU Tisch Kanbar Institute of Film & Television
    Hey there! I'm considering applying for 2026 class, and was wondering about the 120pg guideline, is it expected we hit 120pages for the full...
    • PATTY E

Latest Articles

Latest Accepted Applications

Applications
Articles
Forums
Film Schools
Scholarships
Back
Top