NYU (NY) 2010 (1 Viewer)

Originally posted by film212film:
Jon Tintori told me all the intervieews had been scheduled and they had scheduled X people a day for the next 2 1/2 weeks...
and then interviews would be done, they would review everyone, and people who get in get a phone call midmarch-- everyone else a letter april 1
that being said I did ask as requested by people on the board.... I am sorry if it isn't good news

thanks for the update. and to everyone who is scheduled for an interview...good luck and I hope you do well if admitted to NYU!

as for me. i'm off to prepare for my Columbia College Chicago interview!

but first, i'm gonna break out the bottle of whiskey (pour some out in remembrance of my NYU application), find my handy dandy notebook, and get back to writing! If you are in the same boat as me and did not get the NYU interview this year just keep working hard and follow what you are passionate about! No admissions committee can determine your worth or fate as a filmmaker.

I'm glad this forum is around. It helped ease the pain of rejection lol. It would've been much worse if I spent the entire time waiting until April with no information about the process. Its like if your dog has been sick for a while and you know its time is coming. You'd be sad when it dies, but not as sad as if it just got hit by a car one day outta the blue. ( i apologize if any of you have recently lost a dog).

good luck to everyone and I hope to see your features playing in the theatre right next to mine one day!
 
Thanks for the info film212film.
Wow, I am quite annoyed with NYU. Why can't they just send out a rejection letter to those they aren't interviewing if they have scheduled all their interviews already? Why the need to drag out the process and pain for us?

I need booze.
 
For all those disappointed souls still wandering aimlessly on this forum.

Hope this can bring a bit of a smirk to your face . . . at least under the circumstances.

Email I sent today!

"To: tisch.gradadmissions@nyu.edu
Subject: Admissions Inquiry

Can you please send out freaking rejection e-mails already?

After thinking about it, I doubt that it is even possible for the graduate admissions office to review all the applications submitted anyways?

How many were thrown out unopened? Simply ignored after the initial slots were filled to capacity?

What a gimmick.

Can I demand my refund of $70 please.

Or maybe that's the going rate for an email these days.


Yours truly,

A pissed off prospective student who is trying to vent."

Damn do I feel much better after getting that off my chest. Hopefully I be will saving myself a lot of money on my future therapy sessions. Or on the other hand possibly contributing towards the need.

Peace out!
 
Originally posted by Devin W.:
For all those disappointed souls still wandering aimlessly on this forum.

Hope this can bring a bit of a smirk to your face . . . at least under the circumstances.

Email I sent today!

"To: tisch.gradadmissions@nyu.edu
Subject: Admissions Inquiry

Can you please send out freaking rejection e-mails already?

After thinking about it, I doubt that it is even possible for the graduate admissions office to review all the applications submitted anyways?

How many were thrown out unopened? Simply ignored after the initial slots were filled to capacity?

It's actually quite simple how every application can get looked at: spread the work around to a lot of people. It's systematic and it works.

Every application needs to get looked at and they do. The school wants the best applicants, just as much as the students want to attend the best schools.

After composing and sending off your trite and ignorant email, do you really wonder why they didn't contact you for an interview?
 
Yeah, I didn't get asked for an interview but seriously have you never applied for school before. That was a pretty awful e-mail.
 
Devin:

While I applaud boldness working for a college I can tell you that was a flawed move. I don't know if you thought that by being rude you would somehow stick out for next years applicants, but trust me, schools, even art schools, are hyper sensitive and cautious of wacky students and their emails, particularly after Virginia Tech. Do what you want but I'd ask someone to review your emails next time before hitting send. Just advice from the rejected cohort.
 
So, just to clarify, if I have not heard anything about an interview as a screenwriting applicant, I can pretty much guarantee it's a no from NYU?
 
Not necessarily. I went back and reviewed the posts from the past couple of years. It seems that a couple of people at least got e-mails stating that they would have interviews via phone which we would have gotten (comparatively) this week and not necessarily a request to appear in person.

The only weird thing is, that this year (out of lurkers who would be willing to post & regular posters) I haven't seen a single person say that they had an interview for DW. Of course, this could mean, that no one available to post was selected. It would also probably be a correct supposition to speculate that this year there probably is a larger pool of applicants.

So ... yeah. It's possible no one here was chosen. It's possible they'll do phone interviews and they haven't chosen yet since last year it seems people were notified one day and got a phone call a couple of days later. It's possible there will be no interview. It's possible through skill and practice humans will one day gain the ability to cause people's heads to explode with a stray thought. Who knows? Who knows?
 
Originally posted by wyy123:
Yeah, I didn't get asked for an interview but seriously have you never applied for school before. That was a pretty awful e-mail.

Devin,
I'm sorry but I must say I found your email quite disturbing and I'm in agreeance wyy123. By the way, I took a look at their website (http://gradfilm.tisch.nyu.edu/page/faculty.html#145) and discovered they have 19 full-time faculty. Given the high number of faculty members, I could safely assume that each and every applicant was reviewed. When you do the math 1,500 applications isn't a lot once divided evenly over 19 individuals. Also, you have to remember that most Graduate programs (including film schools) have committees whose sole job is to disqualify applicants. For example, those who didn't follow directions, those who sent in their application late, those who went over the word limits, etc. etc. So by the time the true amount of applicants go to the respective faculty member that original number of 1,500 could have been drastically dwindled down. Lastly, you might want to reconsider sending such emails in the future. Also, I wouldn't be surprised if the Big 5 (Columbia, NYU, USC, UCLA, and AFI) or any other school for that matter had monitors on this site. You wouldn't want to open mouth and insert foot. Besides it could or may affect your chances for this year or next. Just my two cents and you can take it for whatever it's worth.

SilverLenz
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yeah, Devin...man, I think that was a bad move. For one, it's not like it is April or May and you still haven't heard anything while everyone else has been accepted. It's only February. And decisions, I think according to NYU, aren't even made until later. So I'm sure they received your email and thought, "What in the world? What's this kid's problem?" We all have to wait. All your email proves is that you don't want to wait and that you really don't respect the Admissions people nor the school, collectively.

As someone who's worked in a graduate Admissions office for the past 2 years, I can tell you for sure, this: if you sent that kind of email to our school, we'd red flag you in the system and that way, if you ever tried to apply again you would for sure not be admitted based on that instance.

Furthermore, the world of film/tv is a world built around collaborative relationships. If you screw over someone or act like you're entitled to not wait for something everyone in the world has waited for, you're only hurting yourself in the process. I've known people who've moved out to CA to become actors/actresses and they get extra gigs and try to make it big by defying the director/producer on set. Same not-smart-move. Hollywood (this world) is about knowing your place, respecting others, working hard from the bottom up. It's the exception, not the rule, when a person becomes famous overnight (and this, is rarely ever the case for filmmakers--it's more likely to happen to actors/models, etc.).

So if you applied to other schools, like wannabe2 advised, I'd suggest you seriously have someone else read your email (especially if it's angry) if you want to write one out like that again.

Best to you.
 
this entire process has been fun and rewarding. although nyu may reject me in the end, i have been accepted into a top five and im not so sure what that says about nyu if they do reject me or others in the same situation in the end. i say its not meant to be and move on. on that note, has anyone watched that nyu film school documentary series? i watched it to get a flavor of the university and really wasn't that blown away by the quality of the program. in fact, one of the students didn't even know how to make a film and subsequently dropped out! guess they made the right admissions decision and i have no doubt that they will continue to do so...
 
I interviewed yesterday and I'm not feeling great about it.

Wondering what kind of weight the interview has?

I think my application was strong, but after getting to the interview round does the application even matter anymore? Are admissions decisions made based only on the interview at this point?

Freaking out!
 
This is something I am very curious about too.

I thought my interview went well. It was very fast paced, but I surprised myself at how creative i was under pressure.

Anyway they are taking approx 2/5 people they interview... are the interviews what makes or breaks everything? Is everyone equal at the point of the interview?!?!?!?

this old post I found was somewhat helpful--

http://forums.studentfilms.com...?r=96310834#96310834

but I want more info, do the faculty all get together and go over the top 50 of the 100 interviews together?
 
Good luck to those who had interviews already (It's hard to post that, because I didn't, sniff, but I honestly hope you do well)!

NYU was one of my top choices, but at this point, I just want to go to film school!!

Can't wait till March/April comes around and all this is settled : - )
 
xWow, I was definitely not expecting the passionate and zealous responses from duders, wannabe2, Silverlenz, Nville26, and gh0sted on the topic of my email.

To be honest the previous post and message was a joke constructed to summarize the hidden fears, anxieties, and anger that those students who have been waiting for notification from New York University have not received for the amount of money they gave to apply.

I wrote the email for novelty value, to bring a laugh or smirk to those who haven't interviewed, or those who might be frustrated that theyre hard work and blood sweat and tears have been unrecognized. They probably do not review all the portfolios anways and I am just trying to make a point.

THE EMAIL WAS NEVER SENT OUT! FYI

To those who responded that couldn't decipher the playful and sarcastic tone of my message, I really don't know what to tell you besides to lighten up a bit and try not to over analyze a simple "joke," maybe laughter is what you need to pull those sticks out of you know where.

I did'nt want to touch the responses because they were so intense but hell why not, what have I got to lose.

Personalzied messages for those 5 who responsed, courtesy of DEVIN!


Duders,
I appreciate your proclaimed subjective view in "how you think the admissions process works," and your comments towards its efficiency, but in the end that is mere opinion. I doubt anyone, besides those actually working for the department themselves actually know. Who are you to expand on the process? Through your response I can see why from your train of thought, you will probably slip up eventually.

wyy123,
Yes it was an awful e-mail, and written in reflection of a specific ideological value. The statements were aimed in criticizing the direction of the system and to rattle the cage to the possibility of what might actually be the case. Portfolios being neglected. I can assume this because mine was outstanding and original.

Wannabe2
To compare the email and tone of that post and fictitious email to something that would be considered even close to the"Virginia Tech massacre" is a powerful statement, which sounds ridiculous. Being rude, in actuality, is calling you out on your dumbfound analogy and making you rethink your response. If you think that was bold you are greatly inexperienced to real world work ethic and possibility of peoples effect.

Silverlenz,
If you find that alleged e-mail truly disturbing, then you must have the stomach of a toddler. Also it is impractical to think that the entire faculty of the department takes part in the admissions process. Also for thinking graduate admissions is monitoring a third party forum, that sounds paranoid, if not a waste of their resources, if they have received a record number of applications this year.

Neville26,
Sending that e-mail would obviously have been a bad move, but it was fake, so don't think too much of it. It would definitely have confused and bewildered the admissions board and hopefully make them rethink there tactics of ignoring portfolios and not reviewing candadites who are qualified. Other then that, I do not see the connection between writing this e-mail, as a sign for not having collaborative relationships, or defying those in power. Those comments seem to go off on a tangent and prove a unecessary point that you felt a need to make to prove your worth.

Gh0sted,
Your respnse is most “pious” as they come. I can see why you were not invited for an interview. Who are you to tell me to focus my negative energy elsewhere? You in a sense are projecting your negativity on me.You do not know me and to call my actions “pathetic” is only a reflection of your own insecurities. If you need to go to Haiti to make a career out of yourself, that shows “something about your character” in what you need to do to become successful. Why not make it in the states. Trust me there will be no positive energy flowing from my direction to you.

Nobody wants to work with some one who can't take a joke. As this message is probably outside the rules of this forum, I wish it remains posted long enough for you folks who have the nerve to unnecessarily respond to a joke badly. For others who can take one, read my response, and post your response. Especially for those who are angry with the process and need a laugh to enjoy, please read my fictitious email to get a laugh off/ Maybe some other people will actually appreciate it.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Duders,
I appreciate your proclaimed subjective view in "how you think the admissions process works," and your comments towards its efficiency, but in the end that is mere opinion. I doubt anyone, besides those actually working for the department themselves actually know. Who are you to expand on the process? Through your response I can see why from your train of thought, you will probably slip up eventually.

I know EXACTLY how the process works - there is nothing subjective about it. The department is extremely small. It is well known within the department (faculty, students & staff), who is on the admissions committee and how it works. The program is an extremely close knit community. At the interview Tintori spells out exactly how the process works. It's completely transparent, once you are within. I guarantee, that within 1 year of being in the program you will know EVERY SINGLE person including those 2 years ahead of you. There are no secrets.

The school owes you nothing, other than to inform you of your status by the time that they mentioned. Which they will. The fact is that they haven't accepted anyone yet (the interviews go on for a bit), so how can they reject anyone? In theory, if all of the interviews are awful, they can reassess the people they didn't interview. Obviously, the chances of this happening are next to none, but they need to cover their asses.

I don't understand your 'anger' at the process. It's a process that has been in effect for decades (I'm not saying it's perfect), but every single person in the program has dealt with the same frustration, eagerness and anxiety that applicants deal with. It's part of what you sign up for.

If you looked at several years of posts along these same lines, you would see that things are pretty normal (give or take a couple of days).

Your whole attitude just stinks of sour grapes, when we all know you'd be singing a different tune if you had been notified of an interview.
 
Log your film school application with our Application Database so that we can improve our admissions statistics.



Users who are viewing this thread


Latest Accepted Applications

This Application in the Scattergram

Exclusive Supporting Member Benefits

Peak behind the admissions curtain. Supporting Members unlock full access to insightful data, interviews, and more...

Instant Keyword Alerts
Visible Supporter Badge & Highlighted Profile
Share Subscription with one family member or friend

Instant access • Cancel anytime

Latest Film School Reviews

  • USC School of Cinematic Arts
    5.00 star(s)
    Best Film School in the world
    I am eternally grateful to everything USC has done for me, especially as an international student; it has closed learning gaps that would have...
    • Anonymous
  • Sacred Heart University - School of Communication, Media & the Arts
    5.00 star(s)
    FTMA: Professional AND Personal Growth
    FTMA was an integral part of my development process as a filmmaker and a human being. Through this program, I learned discipline, follow-through...
    • Anonymous
  • Antioch University - Low-residency MFA in Creative Writing
    5.00 star(s)
    Great Program
    Obtaining my MFA is something that I have considered for many years. However, it never seemed like the right time. Antioch made it the right time...
    • Anonymous
  • Antioch University - Low-residency MFA in Creative Writing
    5.00 star(s)
    A Deeper layer to writing, art and connection
    Antioch's MFA in Dramatic Writing is unlike any program I've encountered. What sets it apart immediately is the mentorship model — your mentors...
    • Anonymous
  • NYFA - New York Film Academy (Los Angeles Campus)
    1.00 star(s)
    Military Avoid as if your life depends on it
    This school is a freaking NIGHTMARE. I was sexually harassed and bullied by foreigners in my class and the school took their side because they...
    • Anonymous

Latest Applications

Latest questions

Latest Articles

Latest Accepted Applications

Applications
Articles
Forums
Film Schools
Scholarships
Back
Top