By the way, Witt, I disagree with you about UCLA and USC being roughly equal. UCLA's producing program is nowhere near as strong as the Stark Program. Of course, it is still a very good program and highly motivated students will still succeed in it regardless. (And I bet Max will get in!) But UCLA is better known for its screenwriting program than it is for producing. In my opinion, UCLA screenwriting is the top and USC producing is the top.
The main difference between UCLA and USC (in terms of producing programs) is that UCLA is very much about becoming a "director's producer." USC, on the other hand, emphasizes the idea that the producer is the key creative force that drives the entire project.
The problem with NYU (which used to be my top choice a few years ago) is that even though you learn from an amazing curriculum at one of the top film schools in the world, and you get an MFA and an MBA, you still realistically have to move back to LA at the end of it. Hollywood has shifted so that 95% of film happens in LA and maybe 5% happens in NY. And the stuff that happens in NY tends to be more "indie." On that note, the problem with Columbia is that it is very art house, which isn't the type of cinema I'm particularly interested in learning about in school. I love art films, but I'd rather learn the ways of the commercial Hollywood blockbuster. I believe in mastering the rules before you decide to break them.
AFI is a little bit old school. To me, its "brand image" centers on classical Hollywood. It has also lost some of its prestige over the years, I feel. Hence the deadline extension from December to May.
After pretty extensive research, the reason why I chose not to apply anywhere else besides Stark is because none of the other programs offer me as much as Stark does. I don't just want to go to grad school in general -- I want to be a producer. And of all the grad producing programs, for me, Stark is the one that best suits my own goals and interests. It's the only one worth the time and money commitment, for me personally.
Obviously, people on this forum have applied at a lot of other places, too. And the other comparable programs DO have a lot of other things to offer and they are still very good. But for me, my choice is between USC or getting a job. Not USC vs. UCLA/NYU/AFI/Columbia/etc.