I'm looking off-campus. If you can afford on-campus go for it! I'll be looking probably in Brooklyn, luckily I have friends there that will be looking as well and have asked if I want to room with them. The main disadvantage, in my eyes, is the time it will take to get to and from campus. I'm based in Michigan but I used to live in Harlem for just under a year in 2016 and used to have to ride the subway from home to work in lower Manhattan anywhere from 30mins to an hour depending on how the subways were that day. Nights and weekends are often hell for the subways with construction and reroutes. Also the L train is supposed to be closed down for sometime coming up, which will be a major blow for transportation from Brooklyn to Manhattan. Just things to look into and consider. All of this hell for me outweighs the ridiculously crazy expenses of living on or near campus in the West Village or East Village. Though if I could afford it, I would love to live in those neighborhoods.
Someone passed this on to me, might be of some help:
Log into Facebook | Facebook